Moderating Discussions

Discussion Resource: (Horton, W., Designing for the Virtual Classroom, E-Learning by Design). Copyright 2006 John Wiley & Sons Inc. Used with permission from John Wiley & Sons Inc. via the Copyright Clearance Center.

Chapter 9, “Design for the Virtual Classroom” (pp. 463-471)

 

        In “Design for the Virtual Classroom”, Horton notes that “Good discussions do not just happen. They are designed and crafted to provoke deep thought and continual improvement of ideas and opinions” (2006, p. 464). Sometimes instructors design the discussions themselves, and other times they are already build into the course. However, good instructors understand how to moderate in such a way that engages students and challenges them to deeper thinking.

        This week’s resources explain characteristics of a good moderator. Read through Horton’s characteristics and suggestions for good moderators. Think of two examples from your own experience, one good and one bad, of an instructor/moderator you have encountered. Explain what you would have done the same or differently in each situation.

Initial Post

1-Below Standard

2-Minimal

3-Acceptable

4- Exceptional

Organization/Focus

Post not based on the resource. Lacks focus and strays from the topic.

Post loosely focused on resources. Loses focus at times throughout the post.

Post based on resources presented. Clear main idea. Maintains focus throughout.

Post based on resources with other resources cited to support ideas presented in required resources. Post is extremely well organized and maintains focus. Thoughtful conclusion.

Analysis

No analysis or low quality analysis of material. Lacks understanding of resources.

Post shows shallow understanding of resources.

Shows adequate understanding of resources.

Shows deeper level of thinking. Applies ideas in resources to outside examples. Ties ideas together well.

Style

Incomplete sentences with more than 6 grammatical errors.

Simple language and sentence structure. 5-6 grammatical errors.

Well-developed sentences. Less than 4 grammatical errors.

Well-developed sentences using grade appropriate vocabulary. Less than 3 grammatical errors.

Sources

Quotes not cited or incorrectly cited. No Works Cited page.

At least one quote used and correctly cited. Uses APA style with minimal errors.

At least 2 quotes cited correctly. Uses APA style with no errors. Works Cited included.

At least one additional resource presented. Post includes correctly cited quotes, APA style, with Works Cited page.

Response to Peers

No response to peers or negative or inappropriate responses.

Responds to at least one other post. Provides minimal feedback. Comments may stray from the topic at times. Response may be late.

Responds to at least two peers. Provides focused and thoughtful feedback. Provides examples from personal experience.

Shows respect for others and leadership in discussion. Provides encouraging and constructive feedback. Challenges deeper thinking in others. Provides outside resources and examples.

Grade/Comments

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Preventing Plagiarism

What plagiarism detection software is available to online instructors?

 

            Though Dr. Palloff states that there probably isn’t much difference in percentage of cheating or plagiarism online versus the traditional classroom, I do think it’s something that we as instructors have to be consciously aware of. Chao, Wilhelm, and Neureuther note that most plagiarism occurs because students “have underdeveloped paraphrasing skills and they may not know when and how to acknowledge secondary research in their writing” (2009, p. 32). In this their study, students in experimental groups received instructor led training, exercises, and were given resources to help them understand what constitutes plagiarism and how to avoid it. Chao, Wilhelm, and Neureuther also found that many students became confused when they looked at different citation styles (2009, p. 33). When they were given resources like Purdue OWL, students were more likely to cite correctly. Students were also shown examples from TurnItIn, an online plagiarism detection software, and asked to use this resource. After the education and resources were given to students, they did find a reduction in plagiarism when compared to their control group.

            There are so many resources like TurnItIn available to instructors. Matt Petronzio (2012) gives a great list of resources on Mashable.com that includes TurnItIn, PlagiarismChecker.com, and many others. I think that programs that require students submit their own work are the best option. I think that the act of loading their own papers makes students consciously consider whether or not they plagiarized. Just having the threat a possibility of a teacher checking is not as effective as being sure your work is going to be checked every time.

           

How can the design of assessments help prevent academic dishonesty?

           

            I think instructors have to think a little deeper when designing assessments to prevent dishonesty. In our video, Dr. Palloff suggests asking students to take a step further and apply the knowledge they have learned. This way, they aren’t just spewing information from sources, they are thinking about what they have learned and using it in a separate situation. I also think assignments where students record themselves (voice or video) also help with dishonesty. They can’t hide behind the online curtain, and I would imagine that they are more likely to present original work. Discussions are also great, especially when they request that information learned be applied to personal experiences. Projects

 

What facilitation strategies do you propose to use as a current or future online instructor?

            Education and resources concerning plagiarism are the route I would take. I think that having a module at the beginning of a course to help students understand common mistakes is the best way to avoid these mistakes. I do agree with Chao, Wilhelm, and Neureuther that many students really don’t understand what constitutes plagiarism. In fact, I found this to be the case the first time I assigned an online research project to sixth graders. I so wish I had given a few lessons on paraphrasing and proper citation before I had assigned the project. Many of my students were shocked to have their projects returned. Even some parents seemed unaware that what their students had done was wrong, even the ones whose students had not written anything at all in their own words. I also plan to demonstrate for students the online plagiarism detector I will use and to explain to them that their work will be returned for a rewrite if I find that they have plagiarized. Students do not like having to do their work over, so I think this would work well as a deterrent.

 

What additional considerations for online teaching should be made to help detect or prevent cheating and plagiarism?

           

            I think it’s really important for students to see proper paraphrasing and citation from their teachers. Whenever I am teaching a lesson, I make sure I cite sources in my presentations. I always draw my students’ attention to the resources at the end, making sure they understand why I included these sources, why I deem them reliable, and how I cited them in my presentation. I also think it is important to help students understand how hard people work to have their writing published in academic journals. Often, students don’t see it as a big deal. They’re just words to them unless they understand their value to the researchers, authors, and academic community.

 

Resources:

 

Chao, C., Wilhelm, W., & Neureuther, B. (2009). A study of electronic detection and pedagogical approaches for reducing plagiarism. Delta Pi Epsilon Journal, 51(1), 31-42.
Retrieved from the Walden Library using the Education Research Complete database

 OWL Purdue University Online Writing Lab. Retrieved from: https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/560/10/

 Palloff, R., Pratt, K. (n.d.) Plagiarism and Cheating. Lecture presented for Laureate Education, Inc. Retrieved from class.waldenu.edu

Petronzio, M. (2012) Use These 10 Sites to Detect Plagiarism. Retrieved from: http://mashable.com/2012/08/29/plagiarism-online-services/

Usability of Technology

When used correctly, technology can be a wonderful platform for learning in an online environment and a great addition to face-to-face environments. When technology is not implemented well or users don’t understand how to use it, it can become a hindrance to learning.

When implementing technology, Boettcher and Conrad (2010) suggest that instructors “just pick one to three that are best suited for your learning goals and discipline” (p. 58). In addition to limiting the number of technologies use, instructors should also take learner characteristics into consideration when choosing which technologies to select.

Cooper and Colwell (2007) speak to instructors to consider disabilities when looking at usability and accessibility. Usability and accessibility to technology are very important, and I think that many instructional designers are unaware of many disabilities and how simple it is to make modifications to design so that technologies are more accessible. I was just in a training for a new online school program that has been made available to my students. When I asked how to turn on the closed captioning for the tutorial, I was told that there isn’t any closed captioning. That’s going to be a problem for a few of my students, and it is such a simple consideration that the program designers overlooked. Technology has to be usable for all members of the class in order for students to collaborate.

Since many of my students have disabilities, I am prefer technologies that have built-in accommodations. One of the best programs I have ever used is Study Island (www.studyisland.com). There are so many features that helped my students. Students can highlight text (difficult words or full paragraphs) to be read to them, they can use different colored highlighters to mark important information in text, and teachers can have the program generate three answers for multiple choice questions rather than four. There are also many additional practice features that students receive remediation on subjects where they struggle. Though this program can be a bit difficult to navigate on the teacher/administrator side, it is incredibly easy to navigate from the student/parent side. In addition, they offer “how to” videos on pretty much every feature and a great support team. These are the kinds of technologies that I love to use. When designers have thought of virtually everything, it is a dream come true for the instructor. Usability and accessibility to needed tools is equally important for the instructor.

Resources:

Boettcher, J. V., & Conrad, R. (2010). The online teaching survival guide: Simple and practical pedagogical tips. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Cooper, M., Colwell, C., & Jelfs, A. (2007). Embedding accessibility and usability: Considerations for e-learning research and development projects. ALT-J: Research in Learning Technology, 15(3), 231-245.
Retrieved from the Walden Library using the Education Research Complete database.

 

Understanding Technology

What is the significance of knowing the technology available to you?

                It’s important to understand the technology available to you, because there may be some benefits of using one technology over another. For online courses specifically, it is important to have a firm grasp on the technology as “to avoid unnecessary frustration” (Conrad & Donaldson, 2011, p. 38). Knowing how to use the technology enhances student communication and ability to gain maximum understanding. The course site or online classroom “is the ‘physical space’ for the online classroom” where “the instructor and students gather, share thinking, ideas, and complete the course requirements” (Boettcher & Conrad, 2010, p. 65). Students have to be able to utilize the technology tools in order to fully participate in this community of learners.

              

Why is it essential to communicate clear expectations to learners?

 

                It’s important to communicate clear expectations so that learners are aware of what is required to pass a course. Boettcher and Conrad (2010) also state that “clear and unambiguous guidelines about what is expected of learners and what they should expect from an instructor make a significant contribution to ensuring understanding and satisfaction in an online course” (p. 55). It is also important in helping “create a smooth and trusting learning environment” (Boettcher & Conrad, 2010, p. 55). Clear expectations let a student know how much time and study they need to devote to a course, and in some cases, may let the learner know whether or not they will be able to manage the course material.

 

 

What additional considerations should the instructor take into account when setting up an online learning experience?

 

                Throughout my teaching career, I have frequently asked my students to complete learning styles surveys at the beginning of a class or course. Conrad and Donaldson (2011) note that an instructor should consider the “individual learning style of the student and his or her comfort with the online environment” (p. 30). Some learning styles may need more support or variety in the online environment than others. In addition to learning styles, the instructor should consider the students’ previous experiences with technology. Even tech savvy students may not be comfortable with new course tools and need practice to be able to use them.

 

Resources:

Boettcher, J. V., & Conrad, R. (2010). The online teaching survival guide: Simple and practical pedagogical tips. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Conrad, R., & Donaldson, J.  A. (2011). Engaging the online learner: Activities and resources for creative instruction (Updated ed). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

 

 

Motivating Students and Sustaining Online Learning Communities

I have been a part of several different types of online learning environments. As a student, I experiences both mixed method environments and fully asynchronous environments. As a teacher, I have been part of a mixed environment where students even had limited face-to-face contact with teachers and other students. What I learned was that it takes motivation on the student’s part to fully build an online community. What it takes on the teacher’s part is understanding the student to know how to elicit that motivation and also to understand what level of motivation is critical for the student to be successful based on the learning environment. Conrad and Donaldson state that “designing and utilizing activities that are appropriate for the various engagement phases of specific learners can promote confidence and success” (2011, p. 11). They also note that “Engaged learning does not simply happen. It requires ‘architectural engineering’ by the instructor” (Conrad & Donaldson, 2011, p. 14). There are many elements on the part of both the instructional designer and the instructor that go into planning for student success.

My first experience with an online course was my teacher certification. It was considered “distance learning” but it essentially was an online experience (for the most part). Though I did have some conference call interaction with my peers and even a few face-to-face orientations, I didn’t feel at all connected to my classmates. My learning community was me, my professor, and fellow teachers at the school where I taught. Though my courses were partly synchronous, I didn’t feel that I was connecting ideas with my classmates.

Here at Walden, the program has been completely asynchronous. The interactions between students are limited to discussion boards and occasional emails (or at least this has been my experience). However, I have had many quality interactions with my professors and fellow students through discussion groups. At times though, I have sometimes felt disconnected on a personal level. Surprisingly, merely having the option of our pictures next to our discussion posts and the use of blogs has helped me feel a little more connected. Sometimes, in a professional setting, the formality causes us to “lose face” and we forget there is a real person on the other end of that discussion post. I think this very minor change to the Walden layout simple but very smart. I also love that there are short videos in each module. This helps me feel connected to a professor, even if it is not necessarily my course instructor. In an asynchronous setting the designers/instructors have to find ways to create those connections so that the students are truly experiencing a meeting of the minds.

As an online teacher, I found that live interactions through phone, online virtual classroom, and through online conferences was absolutely necessary for the majority of students and families. Occasionally, we would have a tech savvy family who took the mostly asynchronous option, but for the most part, those personal connections could be directly related to how the student was performing academically, how happy the families were with the program, and how likely they were to stay at our school.

So, what can I gather from all of these experiences? I think the essential elements come down to reaching out. This can be classified as Analysis in the ADDIE process. Whether it is formal or informal, you have to figure out what you are up against, both as a teacher and as a student. Online students have to analyze their professor, their fellow students, and what is expected of them as far as course work. Online teachers have to analyze student demographics and then behavior to determine what level of motivation and support that student needs. Then it takes a great deal of planning and development, before, during, and after a given course. As online instructors now seem to be taking a secondary role, working within a preset curriculum and online school system, instructors are not as involved with designing the instruction their students receive. Instructors have to be more interactive, actively seeking out those less engaged students. Likewise, students have to be more engaged in pursuing their education. If they can’t figure something out on their own, they have to be persistent in finding the right person to help them. Asynchronous education is not for every student. However, as technology and learning theories develop, we may find way to make it more accessible and pleasing to a larger body of people.

This goes back to Conrad and Donaldson’s comments on “engineering learning”.  I think the focus of asynchronous instruction is constant feedback or evaluation. The engineers of the curriculum may not be the instructors at all. Instructors, students, support faculty, and curriculum designers all have to work together to adjust and change the courses to meet the ever changing needs of our constructivist lean towards education, specifically online learning. Our learning has become so much more independent, but what we can’t forget that we need each other so that our ideas can connect and build into something greater. Often, those connections and ideas are what inspire and motivate us to greater things and a desire for continued learning.

 

Resources:

Conrad, R., & Donaldson, J. A. (2011). Engaging the online learner: Activities and resources for creative instruction (Updated ed.). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Morrison, G., Ross, S., Kalman, H., Kemp, J. (2011) Designing Effective Instruction (6th Ed) Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

 

Resources for Estimating Costs and Time

It’s sometimes difficult for new project managers to know where to start when learning to estimate cost, effort, and duration of time of tasks associated with projects. There are many resources out there, and I found a few that were very helpful.

Markgraf, B. (2013) Six Methods for the Estimation of Activity Duration in Project Management Retrieved from: http://smallbusiness.chron.com/six-methods-estimation-activity-duration-project-management-41782.html

1-      Work Breakdown- Reduce the activity into smaller tasks that individuals perform to more accurately reflect time.

2-      Historical- Use historical data on the same activities

3-      Analogy- Use similar activities carried out in the same company or even by different companies to create a reliable estimate of the duration of the project.

4-      Expert Judgment- This article stated that estimating duration of large or very new projects can be difficult and urged hiring an outside specialist if needed.

5-      Effort- This article mentioned that time needed to be allowed for obtaining materials and then added to labor time.

6-      Unit- PM will need to calculate the duration needed to create certain units, but will need to be careful that units do not change from company to company (or country to country).

Westland, J. (2011, June 23) Project Management: 4 Ways to Manage Your Budget [Weblog] Retrieved from: http://www.cio.com/article/684978/Project_Management_4_Ways_to_Manage_Your_Budget

                I really liked this blog because it highlighted the importance of continuing to revisit the budget throughout the project. We have been talking a lot about planning and calculating costs, but this article brought up a really good point in saying:

“A 10 percent budget overrun is far easier to correct than a 50 percent overrun. Your chances of keeping the project on track with frequent review of the budget plan is far greater than if you forecast it once and forget about it.” (Westland, 2011)

This article also talks about revisiting resources and how they are being used, communicating with the team, and managing scope. I thought it really brought the budget into perspective for me. I think it is easy to project what you think you might spend, but with separate departments, many people working on many parts of a project, I could see where it might get out of hand very quickly. I liked that Westland pointed out ways to keep this under control.

 

MindTools.com

                I love this entire website! Under the project management tab on the left, you can find articles and tools for just about everything you might want. I found an article that explains how to use Gantt charts, which was really useful. There were also several articles on time management, estimating time and duration, understanding and controlling costs, and even several articles on stress management. There were tons of free tools and resources. This one is definitely worth a look!

 

 

 

When in Rome…Communicate Like They Expect You To

This week we were asked to reflect on a message sent from Jane to Mark about a missing report. It was sent by email, voicemail, and delivered in person, and we were asked how we perceived the message after viewing it in each modality. The message was concise and very professional, and simply asked the co-worker to give an ETA on the missing report so that she (Jane) could submit her own report that hinged on data that was contained in the report she needed from Mark. My reflections are as follows.    

Email

The tone seems understanding but very rushed. I am assuming that Jane expects to hear something back today, since she mentions that she understands Mark has been busy today and that the report is missing and she may miss her deadline. She is not specific about which report, so that may cause some confusion. I would not have taken this email as harsh, but a different person might have. If there are already tensions between Mark and Jane, this email may cause more tension.

Voicemail

You can tell by the sound of Jane’s voice in the voicemail that she is understanding that Mark has been very busy. However, you can also tell that she is very concerned about getting the report. There is no hint of anger or irritation in her voice. If I got this voicemail, I would call her back immediately.

Face-to-face

This one surprised me. I was not at all expecting to see Jane smile, but she did. I was expecting to see someone wringing their hands, sweating, probably disheveled. Jane’s facial expressions and body language do not express the same amount of distress and concern that her voice emits. From the face-to-face conversation, I would think that Jane needs to know when she can get the report, but she doesn’t necessarily need the report by the end of the day.

                This exercise was a good example of how communication needs to be handled carefully in the business (and education) world. In more serious situations, an email taken the wrong way can lead to disaster. However, a well-written message can “present factual data more efficiently” and can allow project managers to “choose their words carefully in order to minimize misunderstandings, provide historical records of the information shared, and share the same message with a wide audience” (Portny, Mantel, Meredith, Shafer, Sutton, Kramer, 2007, p.358). In the case of Jane and Mark, there were several elements missing from both the email and the voicemail though. Portny et al. points out that a face-to-face meeting provides opportunity for the audience to ask questions, enables managers to verify that their audiences received and interpreted the intended message, allows the manager to pick up nonverbal cues, and allows interactive discussion (Portny, Mantel, Meredith, Shafer, Sutton, Kramer, 2007, p.358). If Jane had happened to walk by Mark’s cubicle while he was “home”, it would have been a great opportunity for them to work out any issues with the report right away without passing emails back and forth. Face-to-face is my preferred method of communication though, and I know not everyone works that way.

                In our video this week, Practitioner Voices: Strategies for Working with Stakeholders, Vince Budrovich notes that a project manager should “tailor [their] communication strategy to fit the specific needs of each stakeholder”. Though that is not always possible, it is certainly wise to do so whenever possible. He uses an example where he tailored communication for a specific CIO and it came back later to help him. In any case, it is always wise to learn the culture of the company. Each organization has cultural dos and don’ts for communication. In this week’s video Project Management Concerns: Communication Strategies and Organizational Culture, Dr. Harold Stolovitch says that project managers should identify problematic words and analogies. On the flip side of that, it is also smart to be aware of commonly used words and analogies. My last school basically had their own language. We used to pass out “acronym cheat sheets” to new teachers. My first week there, I only understood about half of what was being said in emails and meetings. I made friends and asked a lot of questions. When beginning communication in a completely new environment, you want to give yourself time to assimilate. You also want to give others time to warm up to your own modes of communication (or change them if your stakeholders don’t seem to warm up so quickly). When in Rome…

 

Resources:

Budrovich, V., Achong, T. (n.d.) Practitioner Voices: Strategies for Working with Stakeholders. Lecture presented for Laureate Education, Inc. Retrieved from class.waldenu.edu

Portny, S. E., Mantel, S. J., Meredith, J. R., Shafer, S. M., Sutton, M. M., & Kramer, B. E. (2008). Project management: Planning, scheduling, and controlling projects. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Stolovitch, H. (n.d.) Project Management Concerns: Communication Strategies and Organizational Culture. Lecture presented for Laureate Education, Inc. Retrieved from class.waldenu.edu

 

Project Post-Mortem

                  I have to be honest in saying that my big ideas are sometimes better than my execution of them. Planning is something I have been working on and trying to improve in myself. Most recently, I was put in a position where I was challenged with helping solve some problems within a school that was experiencing a huge surge in growth. The growth was happening much faster than we had anticipated and we were posed with many changes that needed to happen very quickly. We needed to meet as many needs as we could without completely exhausting our teachers.

                Our online classes were going to be quite large, so I came up with the idea of teaching several smaller 30 minute classes where students were grouped by reading and writing ability. This way, we could target additional needs. I offered the idea to upper administration, and they seemed to think it met the need. They told me that we were going to be asked to teach more classes that year anyway and that they liked the idea of grouping students to target different levels. So, administration asked me to continue with my plan, help develop scheduling, and to train my teachers as to how I would like for them to handle these new classes.

                Here’s where it started to fall apart. I had a very short amount of time to put it together, and there wasn’t much time for planning at all. It’s interesting that we talked about stakeholders in our readings this week, because I think that’s where I really fell short in my planning. I didn’t consult many important stakeholders before I made decisions that affected them. I should have included them in the process rather than just telling them what they needed to do. Perhaps if I had asked what they thought we should do, we might have had some even better ideas suggested and might have been better able anticipate some of the hurdles we ended up having to jump. I also think that the project wasn’t carried out the way I wanted because the teachers didn’t hear or really understand what I was asking them to do. I suspect that they were upset that they had not been included in the planning phase and simply stopped listening after they found out there were to be additional teaching sessions. Sometimes planning how you are going to communicate the project is equally as important as planning the project.

                I had consulted with my “authority” and “driver” stakeholders, but I had failed to consult with my “project audience”, “supporters”, and “team members” (Portny, Mantel, Meredith, Shafer, Sutton, Kramer, 2007, p. 285-286). Sometimes the ones below and within the project are the ones who ultimately hold it up, not the ones above the project. If your supporters and team members don’t support the project, and if the project audience doesn’t gain something from the project, it doesn’t matter if the administration likes it. It still isn’t successful.

                I didn’t plan well because we were so pushed for time, but we ended up spending so much time backtracking trying to figure out how we had gone wrong and what we could do to make it work. We had days to come up with a solution and to put something into place, so we were learning and analyzing as we went along, rather than planning ahead of time. Not only had I not involved all of my key stakeholders, I had not clearly defined objectives, I had not clearly defined roles of teachers for each class (or rather I had not communicated these roles clearly enough), there were inaccurate schedules and resource problems, problems with progress monitoring, and poor planning for risks and uncertainties (Portny, Mantel, Meredith, Shafer, Sutton, Kramer, 2007, p.107). I also have to say that I was a weak leader as well. It was really my first time as a team leader, and I began with a pretty major project. I started with a lack of support from many of my team members, who thought I had simply come up with an idea to make them work more hours; therefore, the project as a whole didn’t have a lot of support (Portny, Mantel, Meredith, Shafer, Sutton, Kramer, 2007, p. 108). Portny et al. give so many suggestions on how to correct these problems, and there are so many things that I would have done differently.

                On a positive note, I would like to add that my project did have some positive results. Once the hurdles were jumped and we worked out all the kinks, my idea did prove to be very successful. In the second year, both the teachers, students and parents found that the teaching program did what it was intended to do. Had we had the time to plan it out the first time, before we jumped right in, I do think that it would have been less of a disaster. I think the lack of planning, training, and general communication lead to the breakdown. The structure or bones of the project were solid. We just didn’t have time to fully form it before it was thrown into place. What did I learn? Planning is EVERYTHING!!! When you fail to plan, you are planning to fail (Benjamin Franklin).

 

Resources:

Greer, M. (2010). The project management minimalist: Just enough PM to rock your projects! (Laureate custom ed.). Baltimore: Laureate Education, Inc.

Portny, S. E., Mantel, S. J., Meredith, J. R., Shafer, S. M., Sutton, M. M., & Kramer, B. E. (2008). Project management: Planning, scheduling, and controlling projects. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

               

 

 

Heading Toward an Ocean of Online Learning- A Reflection

Image            Today, it seems as if the world is overcome with technology. We have moved from the small lakes and pools to a vast and growing ocean, where technology and the internet are included in nearly every aspect of our lives. As long as trend with incorporating and relying on technology and internet communication remain in the work place, the same trend will continue to develop inside the education forum. I recently interviewed several people on their opinions on distance/online learning, and I was surprised to find that those I interviewed expressed none of the stigmas or concerns associated with online degrees and/or training that I have heard in the past. The International Association of Distance Learning states that “distance learning is not simply a contemporary trend that will fade away”. They note that, in the future “memorizing facts will have a much lower value, while utilizing information for analysis and decision making will be a critical skill for educational and professional advancement” (IADL.org.uk, n.d.).

            In my opinion, we are on the verge of tremendous changes when it comes to technology and education. With tools such as Web 2.0, I am not sure that whether or not we will continue with the online schooling using the internet as we know it, or if completely self-directed learning associated with Connectivism will take over (Ormrod, Schunk, Gredler, 2008). The other option is that with online learning, being such a vast and all-encompassing trend, that we may find that some occupational fields have a less skilled worker population and move swiftly back in the other direction (of all face-to-face learning). As designers and academics, we need to make sure we continue to research how distance learning is affecting our students and workers. Simonson et al. notes that “as distance education in the United States increases in importance, evaluation will continue to be a critical component of the process of improvement” (Simonson, Smaldino, Albright, Zvacek, 2012).

            Technology is being included in nearly every work, learning, and social environment today. Children are growing up virtually attached to IPads, phones, computers, and various other technology devices. My seven-year-old asked me just the other day if he could get an IPhone for his birthday this year (I said no). When I took him to orientation for second grade, his teacher asked if he already had an IPad, and she encouraged me to send it to school with him daily. His white board (which only replaced the traditional blackboards about 10 years ago) was covered over and had been replaced with an internet ready SmartBoard. Then, I received a letter asking me to sign up for Dogo- an online behavior management program that I can check from my tablet or phone at any time during the day. He will be represented on his tablet or the SmartBoard as an avatar (which he can change and design himself). I was shocked. Pleased, but shocked.

           

            With the inclusion of so much technology into regular second grade core learning, I know that my child is going to be better prepared to pursue anything he wants, including going away to college and securing a better paying job. Just like my husband and I did, he will have the chance to leave this town (even if he comes back later to raise a family). Right now, technology is the key to everything better.

            Or is it? I most recently worked an online job from home. It was harder, I worked more hours, and I received less pay than I did working for a traditional public school. Though I attended field trips and face-to-face trainings regularly, I felt disconnected from my students and from fellow teachers. I just wasn’t happy. I do think that human beings are social creatures. Sometimes technology creates the effect that we are living in some futuristic world where we are physically connected to devices instead of each other. Sometimes I have to peel my child away from video games just to eat a family dinner. I look around restaurants when we are out, and adults and children alike are checking their phones or tablets instead of talking. I think the future, though it will include advanced technologies, will be about us finding balance. One article I read on Prevention Online noted that so much internet can be bad for our health and even went so far as to claim that “Twitter is more addictive than cigarettes” and that “Facebook ruins your self-esteem” (www.prevention.com, 2012).

            As the population becomes more educated with the help of distance education, I think we will relax into valuing family and friend (face-to-face friends), a live work environment (when possible), and less time connected to our devices. I hope that we will not see a shift into a completely altered human brain function because our children are growing up hooked to devices. I hope that we see them get out and run and play. Though they are often more engaged by the extreme technology inclusion being pushed, like the ones in my child’s school, I hope we continue to control the technology and not the other way around.

            For me, pursuing this IDT degree was about survival. You can’t work in a traditional or virtual classroom these days without extensive knowledge of a wide variety of technologies. However, I don’t think that I will play a hand in encouraging completely asynchronous learning in the future. I would like to help teachers incorporate technologies into their face-to-face classrooms. I am a big supporter of flipped classrooms, where students complete their hands-on activities with the aid of their live teacher, while students watch videos, listen to podcasts, and attend lectures from home or as a part of homework. See 7 Things You Should Know About Flipped Classrooms- Educause (Educause, 2012).

            I have also seen how technologies, such as Dragon, can help students with disabilities. However, teachers (especially older teachers) don’t have the resources or the time to keep up with technologies that change from year to year. Even I found that I was having a hard time using the devices because so many changes were implemented each time a new device was sent to us. These devices can mean the difference between a child being able to communicate or not. But if we want to help these students achieve their maximum potential, teachers have to know how to use them. That is my hope, that I will become better acquainted with improving technologies so I can help teachers and students use them properly.

            In the next 5-10 years, I think we will continue to see distance education on the upswing. But in the next 10-20 years, I think we will see it slack off a little, with people seeing a negative change in physical and mental health due to too much technology use. As an educated change agent, I feel it is my role to be aware of the newest technologies but also to encourage and pursue balance. I have seen first-hand how technology can improve quality of life and efficiency in work and education. However, I want to help others make wise choices so that technology is not our “way of life” but just a part of life. If our children are to play in the ocean of technology and online learning, we have to continue to protect them, and we have to teach them to swim.

 

Resources:

 

Educause (2012). 7 Things You Should Know About Flipped Classrooms. http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/eli7081.pdf

 

Ormrod, J., Schunk, D., Gredler, M. (2008) Learning Theories and Instruction: Laureate Custom Edition. New York: Laureate Education, Inc.

 

Raisch, M. (2012). Prevention: Technology Can Negatively Affect Health: Research. Is Facebook Ruining Your Self-Esteem? Retrieved from: http://www.prevention.com/health/emotional-health/technology-can-negatively-affect-health-research

 

Simonson, M., Smaldino, S., Albright, M., & Zvacek, S. (2012). Teaching and learning at a distance: Foundations of distance education (5th ed.) Boston, MA: Pearson

 

The International Association for Distance Learning (n.d.). What is the Future of Distance Learning? Retrieved from: http://www.iadl.org.uk/Article17.htm